A Recap of Our Webinar on Year-End Fundraising and the Planning Calendar
By Whitney Brimfield, Founder, Spark Point Fundraising
Here’s what we know about Giving Tuesday: every organization you’ve ever given to sends at least one email that day. If you’ve donated to a dozen nonprofits over your lifetime, your inbox on December 1st is a wall of orange badges and subject lines that all say some version of “Today only!”
That’s the problem.
If your year-end fundraising plan starts and ends on Giving Tuesday, you’re not running a campaign. You’re just adding to the noise. In the current fundraising landscape where nonprofits are working harder than ever for every dollar, “adding to the noise” is a strategy you can’t afford.
That was the core argument we made at our October 27th webinar, hosted in partnership with Paradigm Marketing and Design’s New Jersey Nonprofit Council. Here’s what we covered.
The Fundraising Landscape Right Now
Before we can talk about Giving Tuesday, it helps to name what’s happening in the sector more broadly, because it sets the stakes for everything else. Nonprofits are getting squeezed from both sides right now. The pool of available funding has shrunk, partly as a result of the federal government stepping back from the nonprofit sector. At the same time, economic uncertainty and the ongoing affordability crisis have made it harder for individual donors to give as generously as they might have a year or two ago.
The result? More organizations competing for fewer dollars, with leaner teams and less capacity to plan.
Most nonprofits know their case for support. Organizations know why people give to us, and they can articulate the impact of that giving. What they often don’t have is the time to plan how to get that message to the people who need to hear it. Development directors find themselves developing and executing a plan at the same time, which is exactly how you end up sending three emails on Giving Tuesday and hoping for the best.
Why Giving Tuesday Alone Doesn’t Work
The concept of Giving Tuesday is genuinely excellent. A day when everyone knows it’s time to make a donation, when generosity is in the cultural air! The problem is what most organizations do with it.
If Giving Tuesday is the one big moment your year-end campaign is built around, you’re missing the opportunity to do what actually builds donor trust and drives bigger gifts: a sustained series of communications that educate donors on what you’ve accomplished, what you’re planning, and why their support matters right now.
You can’t do all of that in one day. Research suggests it takes 25 to 30 touches to build the kind of trust that moves a donor from casual supporter to committed advocate. Three emails in 24 hours don’t count as three touches, especially not when every other nonprofit in your donor’s network is doing the same thing.
The organizations that get the most out of year-end aren’t the ones with the cleverest Giving Tuesday subject lines. They’re the ones who’ve been showing up consistently since August with impact stories, program updates, and stewardship touches. By December, they’re asking someone who already feels connected, not someone who needs to be convinced from scratch.
How to Use Giving Tuesday Well
None of this means ignore Giving Tuesday. It means use it strategically as one element of a larger campaign, not as the campaign itself.
One of the best ways to use it: a matching challenge.
Here’s how it works: before Giving Tuesday, you secure a matching commitment from your board or a group of your most committed donors. On the day itself, every dollar given is matched up to your total match amount. This approach works for a few reasons:
- It gives your board a structured, low-risk way to participate in fundraising. Board members often have anxiety about asking for money; this gives them something concrete and comfortable to execute.
- It creates natural urgency for donors without requiring a cold ask.
- It tells a story about organizational strength (i.e. your board believes in the mission enough to put their own money behind it)
Remember, someone has to manage this campaign, keep the board accountable, and integrate it into a larger messaging strategy. If you don’t have that capacity right now, a simpler Giving Tuesday approach is fine, but don’t let it become your only year-end move.
What to Do Instead of (or in Addition to) Giving Tuesday
If you have limited time and energy for year-end, here’s where Whitney recommends spending it:
Call your major donors. Not email — call! Around Thanksgiving is a natural moment to reach out and thank your top supporters for the year’s generosity without asking for anything in return. Split the list among your board and staff and have everyone call the donors they know. Let them feel appreciated before the ask comes.
When you do ask, ask for more. When you follow up with your major donors for a year-end gift, ask for 20% more than they gave the previous year. Not everyone will say yes. But many will, and those increases compound over time. You can’t get the gift you don’t ask for.
Map your mid-level and lower-dollar donors too. The major donor relationship is the most time-intensive, but the same logic applies across your donor pyramid. What touchpoints are you building with your 100–499 donors? Your lapsed donors? Your first-time donors from last year? Even a rough map helps you see the gaps.
The Planning Calendar: Your Real Year-End Asset
Here’s the bigger picture: year-end is hard when you’re trying to plan and execute at the same time. The organizations that handle it best are the ones who planned it already.
That’s what a donor communications calendar does. It maps out what you’re communicating, to whom, and when across an entire year. Your calendar should include:
Major donor cultivation and stewardship
- Mid-level donor touchpoints
- Lower-dollar acquisition and retention
- Newsletter cadence
- Annual report timing
- Year-end campaign sequence.
When you have that calendar built in advance, year-end stops being a scramble and becomes an execution. You’re not asking “what do we do?!” Instead, you’re asking “what does our plan say to do next?”
The next time you have a planning window, even an afternoon, use some of it to sketch out your donor touchpoints across the year. What would you want to have said to each segment of your audience by December 1st of next year? Work backward from that. The best time to start planning next year’s year-end campaign is right now!
Ready to map out your year-end strategy? Reach out to us at bre@spark-point.com. And if you’re a Spark Point client, ask us about adding a donor communications calendar to your engagement.
